Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Can you provide me one or two examples from this set? I found a list on Wikipedia [0] of currently non-capitalist countries and many of them sound like perfectly nice places, but I am not aware of when they all "industrialized" and what their socioeconomic climate was like at the time and it seems like drilling deeper is going to require a lot of research. So an example or two that you know about would be helpful.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_anti-capitalist_and_co...



Not all of these countries are "non-capitalist." This is a list of parties that are anti-capitalist/communist, some with only one or two seats in their country's parliament.

The introduction to the article even makes this clear:

> Of the 66 states listed here, 9 of them are republics ruled by a socialist, communist or anticapitalist party, five of them are official socialist states ruled by a communist party, of them four of them espouse Marxism–Leninism (China, Cuba, Laos, and Vietnam) while the fifth (North Korea) espouses Juche.

You are probably looking for the current article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_state#List_of_curren..., or the historical article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_socialist_states.


Like I said, much deeper research ;)

Thanks for the links, they are a much better jumping off point. I cross-referenced [0] with the tables on [1] and population data from [2] to build this list for further analysis:

    Country             *ist since          Total wealth (USD)      Mean wealth/adult (USD)     Median wealth/adult (USD) 
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    China               1 October 1949      29,000 billion          26,872                      6,689
                    Pop 2017: 1.386 billion      Pop 1949: 542 million*          Pop growth/year:  12.41 million
                    
    Laos                2 December 1975     22 billion              5,662                       1,382
                    Pop 2017: 6.758 million      Pop 1975: 3.042 million         Pop growth/year:  88,476

    Vietnam             2 July 1976         358 billion             5,391                       2,235
                    Pop 2017: 95.54 million      Pop 1976: 49.81 million         Pop growth/year:  1.12 million

    Bangladesh          11 April 1971       263 billion             2,612                       1,587
                    Pop 2017: 164.67 million     Pop 1971: 66.42 million         Pop growth/year:  2.14 million

    Guyana              6 October 1980      2 billion               5,345                       2,510
                    Pop 2017: 777,859            Pop 1980: 780,153               Pop growth/year:  -62

    India               18 December 1976    4,987 billion           8,976                       4,295
                    Pop 2017: 1.339 billion      Pop 1976: 635.77 million        Pop growth/year:  17.15 million

    Nepal               20 September 2015   40 billion              2,392                       1,151
                    Pop 2017: 29.30 million      Pop 2015: 28.66 million         Pop growth/year:  320,000

    Portugal            2 April 1976        750 billion             89,437                      38,242
                    Pop 2017: 10.29 million      Pop 1976: 9.4 million           Pop growth/year:  21,707

    Sri Lanka           7 September 1978    68 billion              4,802                       2,448
                    Pop 2017: 21.44 million      Pop 1978: 14.53 million         Pop growth/year:  177,179

    Tanzania            26 April 1964       22 billion              858                         510
                    Pop 2017: 57.31 million      Pop 1964: 11.34 million         Pop growth/year:  867,358

    *https://countryeconomy.com/demography/population/china?year=1949

    Missing data for: Cuba, North Korea
Then I noticed the information at [2] could be remixed in several interesting ways. Looking at charts like [3] and [4] was illuminating. It seems like the "outcomes" of some of these countries are not unfavorable, depending, of course, on what metric you choose to measure.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_state#List_of_curren...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_pe...

[2] https://data.worldbank.org

[3] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GNP.PCAP.KD?location...

[4] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GNP.PCAP.PP.CD?locat...


While china is ruled by a nominally communist party, its party is definitely undergoing deliberative market reforms that are inspired by western capitalism.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: