Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think most of these things were actually on Unix/Linux first, just maybe not as pretty as on OS X.


Lets go through the list:

* Spotlight - OS X

* Dock - NeXT

* Spaces - X11

* Software Repositories - Debian [1994]


Desktop search predates OSX with Beagle (unfortunately now defunct)


The first pitch I ever heard for Beagle was 'it's like searchlight', so I always assumed it came later- but I looked it up, and it's hard to tell. inotify 0.8 was announced about a month after Steve Jobs started advertising spotlight, and Beagle grew out of Dashboard which certainly has design documents that indicate they wanted to do that. So... I think you might be right.

On a related note, are you Ubuntu's jcastro?


Funny. Apple takes features from other OSes like Linux. Linux in turn takes features prominent in Apple's marketing strategy for OS X and replicate it in their own.


I'm pretty sure dash (quicksilver/spotlight) and the dock were in osx way before they appeared on linux.


Docks of one sort or another have been around for years. RISC OS had a dock-like icon bar in 1987, GNUStep nicked one from NeXTStep in 1994, and I'm sure there are earlier examples.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: