More seriously, what you say may be true, but that's a stretched definition of "purchasing intent". Google wins here not because they happen to get eyeballs of surfers interested in diapers, but because people actually use Google to find places to buy diapers. That's a tough nut to crack, and the point of the linked article. More generally: facebook has "eyeballs" and page views, but search providers have the people with their wallets already out.
As an example of getting a purchase before the intent is created, LivingSocial presented me with a number of photography-related deals which I bought. When it was time to make a print of a photo I liked, I didn't think to Google for a printing service, I thought "Let me use my LivingSocial on this."
Facebook has way more information about me than LivingSocial, so I assume they could do a better job of that.
Amazon does much the same thing with its recommended items, and it's cute. I'm sure it drives sales, and by extension would be (is? Not sure if Amazon sells ads in that context) worth advertising to. But realistically it's got to be a small part of Amazon's revenue. And Amazon's revenue dwarfs Facebooks.
Honestly my intuition says that there isn't that much money in that kind of "buy this, you don't even know you need it" advertising. Consumers generally know what they want already.
"Buy this, you don't even know you need it" is basically the foundation of American consumerism. It's the concept behind dandruff shampoos, pet rocks, and designer clothing.
BTW, Amazon's revenue dwarfs Facebook's but Facebook made more profit last year than Amazon ($1 billion vs. $900 million).
http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targe...
More seriously, what you say may be true, but that's a stretched definition of "purchasing intent". Google wins here not because they happen to get eyeballs of surfers interested in diapers, but because people actually use Google to find places to buy diapers. That's a tough nut to crack, and the point of the linked article. More generally: facebook has "eyeballs" and page views, but search providers have the people with their wallets already out.